I think a lot of people had made up their minds about Aragorn's Quest when they heard that it was going to be 'kid friendly' and not quite so grim and gritty- which is something more along the lines of what 'Rings fans were expecting. It definitely has a cartooney look, but I like it.
The art style is clean but detailed and actually reminds me a bit of the 'Animated' style statues from Sideshow Toys. Check out the screens after the break and draw your own conclusions but I'm starting to like the looks of this one.
*All screens are from the PS3 version of the game